I fear for the United States of America. I’m sure that there are many possible reasons that come to your head as you read that first sentence, and I may share some of them, but I have a singular fear that in my mind poses the greatest threat to the livelihood of what is still, for now, the greatest nation on earth. I believe it is the same fear that Abraham Lincoln shared when he proclaimed (quoting another notable historical figure) “A house divided against itself cannot stand”.
I fear for the Unity of those United States. As I’ve followed the recent battle for health-care reform I’ve been surprised again and again (even though I know I shouldn’t be) by the eagerness of people to divide over political interests rather than even attempt to unite for human interests. Whether you agree with the bill put forth or not, the bigger issue is that something needed to be done. For decades now fully one-tenth of America’s people have been crippled by lack of affordable access to health care. To say that the Obama administration’s solutions aren’t ideal is fine, but to effectively walk away from the table and attempt to negate the nations’ best chance in decades of putting forth an imperfect but drastically improved approach at caring for its own citizens is to my mind a moral wrong on the part of Republican and many Democrat politicians. But this is not my main point. It is only a recent illustration of the growing concern I have for the well-being and future of our influential neighbors to the south. Watchers of American (or Canadian, or just about any other nation’s) politics will simply say that this happens all the time, and I’m aware and appropriately discouraged by that fact; but it’s the polarity of it in this current American setting- the extremity- that gives me pause.
As the left was mobilized by a grassroots movement that brought a relatively young, idealistic, un-connected, (and in my opinion excellent) man to the Whitehouse, the right was caught stunned- staring agape at their nation being swept away from them by social networking and feel-good hype. As the first year in Mr. Obama’s presidency rolls over, the Right is now mirroring the tools and tactics used by the left and creating its own wave of momentum and support for change. Many cells of this movement are equal to the Left in their idealism but not in their ideals.
I’ve recently come to understand a little bit of what is creating this backlash. There is a huge segment of the population, largely stereotyped (and to some extent accurately) as being located between the coasts and towards the south, who feel that the nation is slipping away from them, out of their grasp. Many see a nation drifting steadily away from the core values on which it was founded. Now the cynic (and lefty) in me wants to say to these people “How can you complain when it was your own guy who started the ball rolling? It was Dubya who greatly expanded the scope and powers of the government and treated your own rights as currency to be spent towards the “War on Terror”. Now you get to take your lumps!” but of course, while there might be truth to that, it doesn’t exactly get us anywhere, does it? The fact is that the nation is steadily polarizing, and the ever-increasing access to information is creating and increasing fringe groups at an unprecedented rate. I will give an example:
If I was dismayed by the Tea Party movement, I am downright fearful of the implications of a group like the Oath Keepers. This is a group committed to protecting and restoring the constitutional foundation of America. Sounds reasonable, right? The problem is that this group caters not so much to genuinely concerned citizens, but to that fringe who easily equate expressing displeasure with armed struggle. Welcomed are the conspiracy theorists and armed militias, the 9/11 “truthers” and the firearms lobbyists. Oath Keepers is made up to a large degree by people in uniform: military, police, veterans, many of whom have strong values of commitment to their country, and many of whom feel to have been cast aside by their country (many Iraqi war vets, for example). They feel that the government is moving towards a Totalitarian state in which they will be forced to surrender their guns, their God, and their rights, and many in this group are ready to take violent action against this. These fears are fanned by fantastic conspiracies of Obama being foreign-born, a Muslim, having a secret Socialist agenda, etc etc. The problem is not so much that there are people who actually believe this stuff- there has always been that population- but that there is well-organized leadership that is willing to connect and exploit these people in a deliberate attempt to undermine an elected government. More moderate Conservative Republicans meanwhile, do nothing to discourage this fringe because they know that their votes may count on it. For now they can only watch and wait for the right time to either adopt or denounce this movement.
I don’t have fears that a second American revolution is on its way (as some within the movement are hoping), but I think that what we could see is a nation completely immobilized by polarity. My main concern is that the rising level of rhetoric, misinformation, and hysteria could trap the country in a fearful paralysis, resulting in an inability to make any economic or legislative progress. And there are people and groups that are deliberately trying to achieve this for their own personal interests, which is why you’re still hearing about Sarah Palin. There is no reason I can think of why she would have any seat at any political table except that she has the populist backing of this disenfranchised group. She is the ill-advised and overconfident spokesperson for millions of Americans who, up until now felt that they had no voice in a world that was changing much too quickly for them. But it’s not healthy for me to think too much about Sarah Palin. To me the most culpable are not those caught up in the theories, or genuinely scared by a growing government, but those who, being in a position of power, choose to manipulate this; willing to deepen division rather than work towards the good of the nation. I hope for the sake of my friends down south that they are able to experience some economic prosperity (which often serves to relieve tensions), some honesty from their politicians on both sides, and a rediscovery of that great Kindergarten teaching- co-operation. That, and maybe Bin Laden. Nothing unifies like destroying an enemy! Okay, maybe that’s pushing it, but the first three would be nice. The consequences will be steep if unity doesn’t happen; not for one side or the other, but for both.